Thursday, November 21, 2024
More

    Fracked LNG is a washed-out bridge to nowhere

    Date:

    By David Suzuki

    In 2011, the David Suzuki Foundation and the Pembina Institute released a report analyzing whether “natural” gas could be considered a “bridging fuel” during the necessary transition from fossil fuels to renewable energy. It concluded that Canada should focus on developing more renewable energy, not fossil fuels, including gas. Yet, after many years, as prices for renewable energy drop and technologies continue to improve, some are still touting fossil gas as a “bridge fuel” — or even a climate solution.

    A couple of new reports, including one prepared for the David Suzuki Foundation, show that fossil gas is actually a costly bridge to more pollution and greenhouse gas emissions.

    Since 2011, we’ve learned more about fossil gas problems, especially considering that most is now obtained from “unconventional” reserves. That means hydraulic fracturing, or fracking, for shale gas, in which difficult-to-extract gas is released and brought to the surface by pumping massive amounts of pressurized liquids and chemicals into the ground to break up rock and rock formations. It’s a relatively expensive process and uses enormous amounts of water.

    One new report finds not only that fossil gas isn’t an adequate “bridge fuel” but that exported gas also has a greater climate impact than coal over a 20-year period. Production and liquefying shale gas to make liquefied natural gas, or LNG, uses a lot of energy. The gas is mostly methane, which is a more potent greenhouse gas than carbon dioxide over the short term. Leaks, deliberate venting and incomplete combustion during extraction, production and transport can cause significant climate impacts. Studies, including some by the David Suzuki Foundation, have found that methane leaks are far higher than industry and governments estimate.

    The Cornell University report, published in Energy Science & Engineering, found that burning the gas accounts for 34 per cent of its greenhouse gas footprint, while “upstream and midstream” methane emissions make up 38 per cent. Including the energy required to produce LNG brings it to 47 per cent. The liquefaction process and tanker transport add to the total. The global warming potential of LNG as a fuel is 33 per cent greater than that of coal over a 20-year period (and is still equal to or greater than coal over a 100-year period), the report concludes.

    “To think we should be shipping around this gas as a climate solution is just plain wrong,” report author Robert Howarth, an environmental scientist, told the Guardian. “It’s greenwashing from oil and gas companies that has severely underestimated the emissions from this type of energy.”

    Focusing on timelines through the lens of election cycles, unimaginative politicians often see gas production as a quick and easy economic boost, and so they buy into industry propaganda and greenwashing. That’s led to support and subsidies to propel a possible LNG-for-export boom in British Columbia.

    new report from Carbon Tracker with the David Suzuki Foundation and the Pembina Institute shows that’s not a viable solution. “Turning Tides: The economic risks of B.C.’s LNG expansion in a changing energy market” finds that continuing and expanding B.C.’s LNG-for-export industry is a risky investment. The International Energy Agency reports that LNG export capacity will exceed demand, which will “depress international gas prices and set the stage for fierce competition between suppliers.”

    Whether the transition is fast or slow, returns will be minimal. As for global markets, large volumes can be supplied at lower prices from producers including Qatar, Australia and Mozambique. Asian markets are uncertain and appear to be contracting. That means the four LNG terminals in B.C. waiting for investment decisions will likely not be able to compete with lower-cost suppliers on global markets.

    No matter how hard the fossil fuel industry and its supporters try to keep their destructive, outdated industry alive, it’s time to face reality. Fracking for more climate-altering gas is not a solution, for the climate or economy. We have cheaper, cleaner and healthier ways to produce energy. We also need to redouble efforts to improve energy efficiency, doing more with less and saving money in the process. There’s no room for more fossil fuel development — whether it’s coal, oil or gas — on a rapidly overheating planet.

    It’s time to leave all fossil fuels in the ground — including gas!

    David Suzuki is a scientist, broadcaster, author and co-founder of the David Suzuki Foundation. Written with David Suzuki Foundation Senior Writer and Editor Ian Hanington.

    Learn more at davidsuzuki.org.

    REFERENCES:

    David Suzuki Foundation and Pembina Institute released a report:

    https://davidsuzuki.org/science-learning-centre-article/natural-gas-climate-change-solution-canada

    Fracking:

    https://www.vox.com/2014/4/14/18076690/fracking

    Fossil gas isn’t an adequate “bridge fuel”:

    https://scijournals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/ese3.1934

    Robert Howarth, an environmental scientist, told the Guardian:

    https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2024/oct/04/exported-liquefied-natural-gas-coal-study

    Methane leaks are far higher:

    https://davidsuzuki.org/press/study-confirms-b-c-oil-gas-industry-government-underreport-fugitive-methane-emissions

    New report from Carbon Tracker and the David Suzuki Foundation:

    https://davidsuzuki.org/science-learning-centre-article/turning-tides-the-economic-risks-of-b-c-s-lng-expansion-in-a-changing-energy-market

    International Energy Agency reports:

    https://www.iea.org/news/geopolitical-tensions-are-laying-bare-fragilities-in-the-global-energy-system-reinforcing-need-for-faster-expansion-of-clean-energy

    LEAVE A REPLY

    Please enter your comment!
    Please enter your name here

    This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

    Please Support SickKids Hospital

    Popular

    More Good Stuff!
    Related

    Joint Statement by Mayor Nuttall, Mayor Greenlaw, Mayor Coughlin & County Warden Clarke:

    Update on Discussions Regarding the City of Barrie’s Boundary...

    Wright/Johns vs Bright/Ignatowich at the Selkirk Red Rock Open Presented by Pickleball Central

    Selkirk Red Rock Open Presented by Pickleball Central Watch the...

    County Gift-A-Lift Fundraising Campaign Surpasses Goal

    Midhurst/October 8, 2024 – Earlier today, the County of Simcoe...

    Teddy Bears Take the Collingwood Museum!

    Collingwood, ON –  The Collingwood Museum is pleased to...

    The Strange Potatoes with Low Down star at our Local Live Lunch

    JULY 31st - 12 till 1:30 - The...

    Let’s leave gas in the past — especially for buildings

    By David Suzuki Heat pumps are more efficient and affordable...

    VIDEO | The Men Who Stole the World (and got away with it) | Best Documentary

    They're bankers, traders, investment funds executives. They forgot all...

    The Virtual Voyage with Social Media Trends

    In a bustling digital realm, where trends spark like...

    Why China and the US are so obsessed with Taiwan | Mapped Out

    The US-China superpower rivalry is on full display in...

    FIREWORKS VIDEO | Happy Canada Day from Collingwood 2024

    We all enjoyed a spectacular fireworks display launched from...

    Trail Tunes event Connects Communities by Trail and by Song

    Trail Tunes – Another Great Reason to Visit Simcoe...

    A Tribute to Congressman John Lewis: Champion of Civil Rights and Justice

    Congressman John Lewis: "Get in Trouble. Good Trouble" Congressman John...

    How Tesla Reinvented The Supercomputer

    Tesla's Dojo supercomputer is a unique new technology in...

    Ben Johns v Quang Duong at the Vizzy Atlanta Open Presented by Acrytech

    Watch the Men’s Singles Quarter Finals match: (2) Ben...

    Rewind At Blue | SATURDAY JULY 20TH – SUNDAY, JULY 21ST

    SATURDAY, JULY 20TH - SUNDAY, JULY 21ST Get ready to...

    Premiere Lease | 123 Happy Valley Rd, Blue Mountains

    Experience the charm of this authentic 140-year-old hand-hewn log...

    County invests in regional hospice and palliative care services

    Midhurst/October 21, 2024 – Last week County of Simcoe Councillors...

    Collingwood Pride Festival: Star-Studded Lineup and Exciting Events THIS July 12-13!

    Emma Nichol Photography Hello and Happy Friday from Pride Collingwood...

    Hey Collingwood! The Town is refreshing its website and wants to hear your ideas!

    Collingwood, ON – The Town’s Communications Division is working...

    Stories from the Street | Where are You Sleeping Tonight?

    By Joan Orr M.Sc. “It’s really hard, you know, when...

    Rest and restore by spending time in nature

    We’re inundated with consumer solutions to every problem. There’s a...

    Staring Romney Getty with a great lunch by TNT at our Local Live Lunch

    Wednesday August 28th – 12 till 1:30 – Romney Getty...

    Collingwood Live & Original Summer Concert Series is back!

    Collingwood, ON – The Collingwood Live & Original Summer...

    Dr. Bridget | Maximize Your Health with Fiber: Practical Tips and Local Finds

    What is Fiber, and Why Does Your Naturopathic Doctor...

    The Sex Expert: “Casual Sex Is Almost Always Dangerous For Women!” – Louise Perry

    Louise Perry is a British journalist and host of...

    Candle Making Workshop with Serendipity Candles | Side Launch Brewing Company

    Wed, Dec 4, 2024 5:30 PM - 7:30 PM...

    Trump, Putin & Co. – Deutsche Bank’s questionable clientele | DW Documentary

    Deutsche Bank managers driven by greed set it on...

    Celebrating Culture and Community: And Then Came Carnival North

    Carnival North Brings Caribbean Vibes to Simcoe County For my...

    Holy Moley shares: How TikTok Could Decide the 2024 American Election

    2024 American Election As the 2024 election cycle heats up,...

    Sunset Manor’s Classic Car Show on August 22 from 4 – 7 pm | The Wasaga Beach Cruisers

    Don't miss out on Sunset Manor's Classic Car Show...

    Yonnhe’ón:we: Indigenous Art Series Call for Artists

    Collingwood, ON – The Yonnhe’ón:we Indigenous Arts Series returns...

    #WOW Tesla FSD Supervised 12.3.4 Reviews

    One of the key features of Tesla FSD Supervised...

    HeART of Red Gala | Campaign for My Friend’s House

    Join us for an evening of beautiful art, food,...

    Mudmen at Shipyard Amphitheatre | July 19th

    Enjoy an evening of Celtic Music & stories from...

    Stay Cool in Collingwood: Enjoy the Comfort of Cooling Centres

    Collingwood, ON – With the high temperatures forecast for...

    Affordable Housing Seed Funding Opportunity | The Town of Collingwood

    Collingwood, ON – The Town of Collingwood is...