Thursday, November 7, 2024
More

    Fracked LNG is a washed-out bridge to nowhere

    Date:

    By David Suzuki

    In 2011, the David Suzuki Foundation and the Pembina Institute released a report analyzing whether “natural” gas could be considered a “bridging fuel” during the necessary transition from fossil fuels to renewable energy. It concluded that Canada should focus on developing more renewable energy, not fossil fuels, including gas. Yet, after many years, as prices for renewable energy drop and technologies continue to improve, some are still touting fossil gas as a “bridge fuel” — or even a climate solution.

    A couple of new reports, including one prepared for the David Suzuki Foundation, show that fossil gas is actually a costly bridge to more pollution and greenhouse gas emissions.

    Since 2011, we’ve learned more about fossil gas problems, especially considering that most is now obtained from “unconventional” reserves. That means hydraulic fracturing, or fracking, for shale gas, in which difficult-to-extract gas is released and brought to the surface by pumping massive amounts of pressurized liquids and chemicals into the ground to break up rock and rock formations. It’s a relatively expensive process and uses enormous amounts of water.

    One new report finds not only that fossil gas isn’t an adequate “bridge fuel” but that exported gas also has a greater climate impact than coal over a 20-year period. Production and liquefying shale gas to make liquefied natural gas, or LNG, uses a lot of energy. The gas is mostly methane, which is a more potent greenhouse gas than carbon dioxide over the short term. Leaks, deliberate venting and incomplete combustion during extraction, production and transport can cause significant climate impacts. Studies, including some by the David Suzuki Foundation, have found that methane leaks are far higher than industry and governments estimate.

    The Cornell University report, published in Energy Science & Engineering, found that burning the gas accounts for 34 per cent of its greenhouse gas footprint, while “upstream and midstream” methane emissions make up 38 per cent. Including the energy required to produce LNG brings it to 47 per cent. The liquefaction process and tanker transport add to the total. The global warming potential of LNG as a fuel is 33 per cent greater than that of coal over a 20-year period (and is still equal to or greater than coal over a 100-year period), the report concludes.

    “To think we should be shipping around this gas as a climate solution is just plain wrong,” report author Robert Howarth, an environmental scientist, told the Guardian. “It’s greenwashing from oil and gas companies that has severely underestimated the emissions from this type of energy.”

    Focusing on timelines through the lens of election cycles, unimaginative politicians often see gas production as a quick and easy economic boost, and so they buy into industry propaganda and greenwashing. That’s led to support and subsidies to propel a possible LNG-for-export boom in British Columbia.

    new report from Carbon Tracker with the David Suzuki Foundation and the Pembina Institute shows that’s not a viable solution. “Turning Tides: The economic risks of B.C.’s LNG expansion in a changing energy market” finds that continuing and expanding B.C.’s LNG-for-export industry is a risky investment. The International Energy Agency reports that LNG export capacity will exceed demand, which will “depress international gas prices and set the stage for fierce competition between suppliers.”

    Whether the transition is fast or slow, returns will be minimal. As for global markets, large volumes can be supplied at lower prices from producers including Qatar, Australia and Mozambique. Asian markets are uncertain and appear to be contracting. That means the four LNG terminals in B.C. waiting for investment decisions will likely not be able to compete with lower-cost suppliers on global markets.

    No matter how hard the fossil fuel industry and its supporters try to keep their destructive, outdated industry alive, it’s time to face reality. Fracking for more climate-altering gas is not a solution, for the climate or economy. We have cheaper, cleaner and healthier ways to produce energy. We also need to redouble efforts to improve energy efficiency, doing more with less and saving money in the process. There’s no room for more fossil fuel development — whether it’s coal, oil or gas — on a rapidly overheating planet.

    It’s time to leave all fossil fuels in the ground — including gas!

    David Suzuki is a scientist, broadcaster, author and co-founder of the David Suzuki Foundation. Written with David Suzuki Foundation Senior Writer and Editor Ian Hanington.

    Learn more at davidsuzuki.org.

    REFERENCES:

    David Suzuki Foundation and Pembina Institute released a report:

    https://davidsuzuki.org/science-learning-centre-article/natural-gas-climate-change-solution-canada

    Fracking:

    https://www.vox.com/2014/4/14/18076690/fracking

    Fossil gas isn’t an adequate “bridge fuel”:

    https://scijournals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/ese3.1934

    Robert Howarth, an environmental scientist, told the Guardian:

    https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2024/oct/04/exported-liquefied-natural-gas-coal-study

    Methane leaks are far higher:

    https://davidsuzuki.org/press/study-confirms-b-c-oil-gas-industry-government-underreport-fugitive-methane-emissions

    New report from Carbon Tracker and the David Suzuki Foundation:

    https://davidsuzuki.org/science-learning-centre-article/turning-tides-the-economic-risks-of-b-c-s-lng-expansion-in-a-changing-energy-market

    International Energy Agency reports:

    https://www.iea.org/news/geopolitical-tensions-are-laying-bare-fragilities-in-the-global-energy-system-reinforcing-need-for-faster-expansion-of-clean-energy

    LEAVE A REPLY

    Please enter your comment!
    Please enter your name here

    This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

    Please Support SickKids Hospital

    Popular

    More Good Stuff!
    Related

    CANCELLED | Strawberry Moon Festival | Milkbarn Sessions | June 22nd

    A night dedicated to celebrate Music, Art and Fashion...

    Burying radioactive nuclear waste poses enormous risks

    By David Suzuki As the consequences of burning dirty, climate-altering...

    The Honeyrunners, Caliber & Lucca Mae | Milkbarn Sessions

    The Honeyrunners, Caliber & Lucca Mae 9:30pm...

    VIDEO | WOW – Tech giants harness nuclear energy to power AI | BBC News

    Technology firms are increasingly turning to nuclear sources of...

    Collingwood and New Tecumseth Cheers to Provincial Funding Announcement of $70M for Water Treatment Plant Expansion

    Collingwood, ON  – The Town of Collingwood and New Tecumseth...

    Reap What You Sow | The Mike Malloy YouTube Channel

    On July 13, 2024, while speaking at a well-attended...

    VIDEO: Cenk Uygur: Trump vs Harris, Progressive Politics, Communism & Capitalism

    Cenk Uygur is a progressive political commentator and host...

    LOCAL LIVE LUNCH starring Motes & Oats and Fish & Sips

    LOCAL LIVE LUNCH 10 Wednesdays! 10 Concerts! 10 Menus! JULY 3...

    Community invited to provide input on waterfront public piazza park

    Collingwood, ON – Exciting news for Collingwood Residents! The...

    LawnShare helps create vibrant, biodiverse havens

    Rooted in colonial history, these barren, thirsty, high-maintenance landscapes...

    OJHL ANNOUNCES PLAYERS OF THE MONTH

    Collingwood, Leamington, Haliburton stars recognized for awesome Octobers West Conference #55 ...

    James Earl Jones | A Tribute to a Legendary Voice and Acting Powerhouse

    Honoring the Resonant Legacy of James Earl Jones Few actors...

    The Divorce Expert: 86% Of People Who Divorce Remarry! Why Sex Is Causing Divorces!

    James Sexton is America's top divorce lawyer, and bestselling...

    COLLINGWOOD MUSIC FESTIVAL Inaugural Performance! The Toronto Concert Orchestra

    Event by Collingwood Music Festival; AD, Toronto Concert Orchestra and Daniel Vnukowski Inspired...

    Georgian Bay News welcomes Dr. Bridget McMaster, ND

    “focus on yourself” Hi Georgian Bay News!  I am Dr. Bridget,...

    Nature-directed stewardship is good for cities and living things

    By David Suzuki For too long we’ve clung to the...

    Global: A Web of Surveillance

    Unravelling a murky network of spyware exports to Indonesia An...

    Jeff Woods Summer Bday Banger | Saturday July 20th

    Mississippi Blues meets Detroit Rock!  It's the Summer Baby...

    A Tribute to Congressman John Lewis: Champion of Civil Rights and Justice

    Congressman John Lewis: "Get in Trouble. Good Trouble" Congressman John...

    Public Survey Regarding Joint Multi-Use Recreation Feasibility Assessment Now Open

    Collingwood, ON – The Town of The Blue Mountains...

    The Great History of Collingwood, Ontario | Bosley Real Estate

    Bosley Real Estate presents: The History of Collingwood, Ontario Source:...

    Youtuber Bank Won’t Let You Withdraw Money | Coffeezilla

    The no-lose "bank" turned out to be a lie....

    Collingwood Festival for Canada: A Canada Day Celebration

    Collingwood, ON – The Collingwood Festival for Canada is...

    Best Electric Bikes 2024 | Top 26 Bikes Tested & Reviewed, All Under $3K

    So what makes an e-bike the best? Well, that's...

    Bright/Alshon v Kawamoto/Martinez Vich at the IHG Hotels & Resorts Bristol Open

    Watch the Mixed Doubles Semi Finals match: (2) Anna...

    VIDEO: How a battle between Barbara Walters and Diane Sawyer affected Connie Chung’s career

    CNN’s Erin Burnett sits down with legendary reporter and...

    VIDEO | Ally Vitally shares “Trump floats the idea of having a Migrant League of Fighters”

    What's Next 'Hunger Games" Once upon a time, in the...

    Town of The Blue Mountains Hires Monica Quinlan as Director of Corporate and Financial Services

    August 30, 2024 The Town of The Blue Mountains is...

    CJ Lewis: 10 Ways to Keep Your Mental Hygiene

    Need a digital diet? As the Internet in its various...

    Jack de Keyzer | July 17 @ Jazz & Blues Live at the Station

    July 17 – Jack de Keyzer – Juno award-winning...

    Black Harvest Festival | Saturday October 26th

    🎃 The Black Harvest Festival returns this Saturday from...

    The Singhampton Sculpture Forest brings joy and inspires visitors

    The Singhampton Sculpture A retired artist and a civil engineer...

    Rewind At Blue | SATURDAY JULY 20TH – SUNDAY, JULY 21ST

    SATURDAY, JULY 20TH - SUNDAY, JULY 21ST Get ready to...

    Join Us on the Escarpment for an Enchanted Evening, Saturday, August 10

    Friends, neighbours, Georgian Bay lovers and supporters. Save Georgian Bay and...

    People want climate action!

    By David Suzuki Most people understand that the climate crisis...

    #REAL | How an Idyllic Retirement Resort became a ‘Financial Prison’

    When retired policeman Geoff Gauci packed up his old...