Saturday, May 3, 2025
More

    Canada is not an economic basket case

    Date:

    Sharing is SO MUCH APPRECIATED!

    By David Suzuki

    In 1987, Canada was caught up in a debate over a free trade agreement with the United States. Economist John Crispo, an outspoken FTA supporter, warned that failing to ratify it would make Canada an “economic basket case.”

    In 1988, Prime Minister Brian Mulroney called an election to get a mandate to sign onto the agreement. The Liberals and NDP opposed it, but the Conservatives won a majority with 40 per cent of the vote. The U.S. and Canada ratified the FTA later that year. A subsequent 1994 free trade agreement included Mexico.

    In early 1988, before the election, I met eminent economist Kenneth Boulding at a meeting in the U.S. With Crispo’s words still bugging me, I asked about Canada becoming an economic basket case if we didn’t sign on and for his opinion of the FTA.

    Boulding answered, “If you want to know how well off you are, imagine that you go to bed and wake up the next morning to find the whole world has disappeared except for Canada and an ocean around it. Would you lack for food? Not when you are one of the bread baskets, not basket cases, of the world. Would you lack for resources — minerals, energy, lumber, fish? Would you lack an educated workforce capable of making everything from clothing to refrigerators and cars?”

    That thought exercise reminds us of our true wealth. Canada is a nation rich in resources and skilled and educated people with a diversity of backgrounds and ideas and should be the envy of the world. But globalization renders us vulnerable to the consequences of war, hostilities and shifts in priorities and makes us poor — even though its initial justification was to reduce the kinds of conflicts the world had just endured in two global wars.

    I later heard Larry King interview Mulroney on CNN. King chided him for the economic slump Canada was experiencing. Mulroney replied that it wasn’t his fault, that he couldn’t control the global economy. So why do we embrace the global economy? The prime minister’s job is to protect people in Canada and our economy, not hand over control to global forces.

    Donald Trump’s election and subsequent actions reveal how vulnerable we are to the vagaries of an unruly leader who couldn’t care less for the wellbeing of people or the state of the planet. His administration during its first term negotiated the most recent North American free trade pact, the Canada-United States-Mexico Agreement. Now he’s tearing that up, recklessly imposing tariffs, then backing off and re-imposing them — sending stock markets spinning and creating economic hardship beyond U.S. borders.

    We need global alliances, now more than ever, but we must also become more self-reliant. We need to reduce barriers to interprovincial trade and create an integrated renewable energy grid. Our governments must prioritize Indigenous rights, title and governance. We need to make sure our communities are resilient in the face of a warming climate, and we must protect our natural wealth, especially water.

    Any trade agreements we join must prioritize human and environmental rights.

    The billionaires and oligarchs who benefit most from global trade don’t care about countries or borders; those get in their way as much as regulations and public institutions. Their consumer-capitalist economic system facilitates and relies on global trade — in part to exploit low-cost labour and lax environmental and human rights standards.

    Current trade also exacerbates the climate crisis. About 40 per cent of global shipping is to transport coal, oil and gas. As Forbes reports, “Shipping emits over 1 billion tons of carbon a year, making it the sixth-largest emitter in the world after China, U.S., India, Russia and Japan” — and that’s increasing rapidly. Curtailing fossil fuel use would substantially reduce emissions from burning the fuels and from shipping, a win-win for the climate. But it would cut into enormous industry profits and, according to current economic thinking, profits are a higher priority than health and survival.

    What’s happening in the U.S. shows how quickly things can fall apart — rules and institutions, checks and balances, international agreements, governing processes that people have long taken for granted. We need to learn from it and come together to protect what we have while continuing to strive for better.

    David Suzuki is a scientist, broadcaster, author and co-founder of the David Suzuki Foundation. Written with David Suzuki Foundation Senior Writer and Editor Ian Hanington.

    Learn more at davidsuzuki.org.

    REFERENCES:

    Economist John Crispo:

    https://www.thestar.com/news/gta/john-crispo-76-political-pundit-fought-for-free-trade/article_4ffce182-cd81-59d8-bfd5-00c720b4a72a.html

    U.S. and Canada ratified the FTA:

    https://www.cbc.ca/history/EPISCONTENTSE1EP17CH3PA2LE.html

    Subsequent 1994 free trade agreement:

    https://www.thecanadianencyclopedia.ca/en/article/north-american-free-trade-agreement-nafta

    Kenneth Boulding:

    Reduce the kinds of conflicts:
    https://history.state.gov/milestones/1937-1945/bretton-woods

    Canada-United States-Mexico Agreement:

    https://www.international.gc.ca/trade-commerce/trade-agreements-accords-commerciaux/agr-acc/cusma-aceum/index.aspx?lang=eng

    Renewable energy grid:

    https://davidsuzuki.org/science-learning-centre-article/Shifting-Power-Zero-Emissions-Electricity-Across-Canada-by-2035

    Must prioritize human and environmental rights:

    https://davidsuzuki.org/story/re-imagining-trade-for-people-and-the-planet

    Forbes reports:

    https://www.forbes.com/sites/nishandegnarain/2020/09/25/loud-calls-for-global-shipping-to-ditch-fossil-fuels-and-meet-climate-goals/?sh=49718442aaf0

    Sharing is SO MUCH APPRECIATED!

    POPULAR

    More Good Stuff!
    Related

    OJHL, CCHL ALL-STARS, TOP PROSPECTS CLASHING IN ‘BATTLE OF ONTARIO’ NOV. 12-13

    July 17, 2024 ….  The best players and top prospects in...

    Attend the upcoming documentary, ‘It’s Been a Long Time Coming’ – PWHL has Broken Barriers!!!

    Lightning Alumna Brings Women’s Hockey Documentary Premiere to Collingwood After...

    Why Is It So Hard to Mass-Produce Housing?

    I'm honoured to partner with Urbanarium (‪@urbanariumvancouver4133‬) to bring...

    BIG COMMUNITY EVENT: Collingwood Blues, CCI Band and Sam Griffiths Birthday @ ‘the Eddie’

    A SUPER FUN FILLED EVENING!!! Go Blues Go!!! https://youtu.be/XwCnVWgiUKk Player of...

    The Legacy of St. Patrick’s Day

    From Religious Observance to Global Celebration St. Patrick's Day, celebrated...

    World #1 Ben Johns Teaches the Third Shot Drop | BONUS VIDEOS

    Every Saturday, Marc Suood shares a pickleball video or...

    Profit Obsession Inflames Environmental Racism

    By David Suzuki Pollution is so bad along the 137-kilometre...

    Ally Vitally shares “Embracing Exercise as a Springtime Ritual of Renewal”

    Spring, a season synonymous with rebirth and rejuvenation, extends...

    Thornbury Summer Antiques Show | Beaver Valley Community Centre.

    The Thornbury Antique & Vintage Show is just over...

    Captain Ship Shepherd shares the History of our Great Northern Exhibition

    Our fair started out on property in Duntroon in...

    Baptiste shares the Top 30 Catchiest Songs from Classic Movie Musicals

    We're still tapping out toes to these songs decades...

    5 bedroom, 4013 sq ft total, all brick bungalow in Mountaincroft is the ultimate in comfort, style and functionality

    $1,169,000 43 LOCKERBIE CRESCENTCollingwood, Ontario L9Y0Y9 MLS® Number: S11924553 This 5 bedroom, 4013 sq...

    HURONIA WEST FIRST RESPONDERS (FIRE/EMS) TO RECEIVE ENHANCED COLLABORATIVE TRAINING

    (WASAGA BEACH, SPRINGWATER AND CLEARVIEW TOWNSHIP, ON) - On February...

    2024 MARKS HIGHEST NUMBER OF MOTORCYCLIST DEATHS IN TWO DECADES  

    (ORILLIA, ON) - With Motorcycle Safety Awareness Week getting underway,...

    Navigating the Divide: American Politics and Elon Musk’s Ascendancy in Early 2025

    American politics appears to be a mix of ongoing...

    Featuring Jamie Ciotka and Sol Kitchen at LOCAL LIVE LUNCH | Wednesday, June 26

    10 Wednesdays! 10 Concerts! 10 Menus! Great food, a fun...

    Catastrophe is only one part of the climate story – The Energy Mix

     Covering climate change is a challenging assignment, not least...

    MULTI-VEHICLE COLLISION ON HIGHWAY 11

    (Orillia, ON) - Members from the Orillia Detachment of the...

    KITCH DEVILLE JR. shares “Pickleballs Next Big Serve: Air Bender vs Big Papa Jimmy”

    Quang Duong and James Ignatowich, without a doubt, have...

    Duncan Bristow VIDEOS | The Mudmen @ Our Collingwood Amphitheatre

    Special thanks to Duncan Bristow for capturing the great...

    Nikola Tesla – The Brilliant Mind Behind Modern Electricity

    The Life and Legacy of Nikola Tesla (1856-1943) Nikola Tesla...

    Ask Gracelyn: How do I know if I’m ready for a serious relationship?

    Dear Gracelyn: How do I know if I'm ready...

    Walking Through the Fire – A Powerful Celebration of Indigenous Collaborations with Sultans of String

    Collingwood, ON - Prepare for an unforgettable evening...

    Can I Add a Garden Suite to My Lot | ATTIMO Homes

    What Every Homeowner Needs to Check First With rising housing...

    County of Simcoe to recognize Age-Friendly Champions

    Midhurst/January 23, 2025 – On January 28, 2025, at 5:30...

    Statement from Mayor Hamlin

    Collingwood, ON - When the first suggestion of President...

    We can all take part in THE GREAT TRANSFORMATION

    By David Suzuki The odds are stacked against people standing...

    ‘Totally new and terrifying’: Trump’s disturbing rhetoric escalates as trial heats up

    With less than six months until the election, Trump’s...

    Ally Vitally shares: Understanding Emotional Intelligence: A Key to Personal and Professional Success

    Emotional intelligence (EI), often referred to as EQ (emotional...

    HeART of Red Gala in support of My Friend’s House

    Join us for an evening of art & entertainment...

    OPP Snowmobile Patrol Provide a Did You Know (DYK) For Young Riders and Parents

    (MIDLAND,ON) - Members of the Southern Georgian Bay OPP detachment snowmobile patrol...

    DRIVER CHARGED AFTER FLIPPING MOTOR VEHICLE INTO DITCH

    (Collingwood, ON) - Members of the Collingwood and Blue Mountains...

    Half the World Has Now Joined BRICS – Here’s Why They’re Winning in 2025

    BRICS just doubled in size and the organization has...

    BIG NEWS: Glacial Erratic and Molecular at Black Bellows | March 22

    Let’s go out like a LION with this evening...

    Town Conducting Poison Ivy Spraying on Georgian Trail June 17-21

    The Town of The Blue Mountains would like to...

    Connie Riet: Why I’m Starting Over at 50 – Life Reset in a New Country

    Starting over again at 50 was not in my...

    Ask Gracelyn: Financial Tensions and the Art of Not Throwing Your Budget (or Each Other) Out the Window

    When Tariffs Become Marital Strife Dear Gracelyn: My partner and...

    Grammys 2025 Red Carpet – BEST DRESSED | Page 6 and WAY MORE

    Your favorite stars arrive at the 67th Annual Grammy...

    Collingwood Live & Original Summer Concert Series is back!

    Collingwood, ON – The Collingwood Live & Original Summer...

    OJHL ANNOUNCES PLAYERS OF THE MONTH

    Lindsay, Pickering, Milton stars recognized for fabulous Februaries March 6,...

    TRAFFIC STOP LEADS TO INPAIRED DRIVING CHARGES

    (SPRINGWATER TOWNSHIP, ON) - The Huronia West Detachment of the...

    The Ambassador: China – Taiwan | Complex Dynamics in Dangerous Times

    China's potential invasion of Taiwan is a complex issue,...

    OJHL 20-YEAR-OLDS TO PLAY OUA TEAMS IN TWO-GAME SERIES

    Players from the OJ will get full student-athlete experience...

    How MSC Cruises Turned a Dredging Site Into a Private Island Paradise | WSJ Booked

    Cruise lines like MSC Cruises and Norwegian Cruise Lines...

    Sharp Eyed OPP Officer Makes Arrest in Overnight Commercial Midland Break and Enter

    (MIDLAND,ON) - A sharp eyed officer from the Southern Georgian Bay OPP...

    Self-Reliant Couple Growing 80% of Their Food on an Incredible Off-Grid Homestead!

    Laurie & Dan are growing 80% of their own...

    VIDEO | BEST PICKLEBALL POINTS from the Sacramento Open

    These are the BEST points from the PPA Tour's...

    Dan Hill & Andy Kim | May 22nd | Meaford Hall

    Wednesday, May 22 - $65 - Dan Hill &...

    Victor Davis Hanson: The Left’s Addiction to Drama

    Charles Maurice de Talleyrand-Périgord, the French foreign minister after...

    County aims to build up local support system for mental health and addictions in region

    Midhurst/October 23, 2024 – The County of Simcoe, along with identified...

    Expanded Ontario SPCA donation helps pets and their people stay warm this winter

    Enables warming centre in Wasaga Beach to become pet...

    OPP Seeking Assistance in Theft of Snowmobile

    (TAY TOWNSHIP,ON)- Investigators from the Southern Georgian Bay OPP Detachment are seeking...

    The Life and Legacy of Mr. Frank McNulty: A Journey Through Music and Culture

    Mr. Frank McNulty - December 27, 1939 - June...

    CBC | 3 Online Safety Tips that Might Surprise You

    During a busy season of online shopping, cyber criminals may...

    OPP Investigate Overnight Robbery in Midland

    (MIDLAND, ON) - A William Street business was the victim...

    The Truth About ADHD | Dr. Daniel Amen

    Uncover ADHD's origins, benefits, challenges, and effective management with...

    Rep. Stansbury: GOP laying the groundwork to ‘eviscerate’ federal funding

    The Ranking Member of the DOGE subcommittee, Rep. Melanie...

    FARZAD: World War 3 Is Closer Than You Think

    I worked at Tesla starting in July of 2017...

    Town of Collingwood Calls for Applications for Vacant Council Seat

    Collingwood, ON - The Town of Collingwood is calling...

    NEW PODCAST EPISODE: CAFC AND EAPON ON PROTECTING SENIORS FROM FRAUD

    (MIDLAND,ON)- Members of the Southern Georgian Bay Detachment of the Ontario Provincial Police (OPP)...

    Smashes, Dinks, Serves, and Streaming: Your Pickleball Video Guide + Netflix Doc!

    The History of Pickleball: From Its Humble Beginnings to...

    Southern Georgian Bay OPP Highway Detachment Temporarily Closed to Public

    Completion Time Increased The Southern Georgian Bay OPP Detachment would like to...

    Chinese Team Controls over 10,000 Drones with Single Computer in Dazzling Display

    In a dazzling display of technological prowess, a Chinese...

    Call for Volunteers to participate on the Family Physician Recruitment Working Group

    The Town of The Blue Mountains is seeking applications...

    HURONIA WEST INVESTIGATION LEADS TO ARREST AND DRUG SEIZURE

    (TOWN OF WASAGA BEACH, ON) - Members of the Huronia...

    John Miller explains why police can’t shoot down drones amid security concerns in New Jersey

    CNN’s Omar Jimenez reports on weeks of unexplained drone...

    Celebrate History, Heritage Week, and Hockey with the Collingwood Museum!

    Collingwood, ON - Collingwood Museum staff invite you to...

    PHI PHI ISLANDS – THAILAND IN 4K DRONE FOOTAGE – Thailand From Above

    Explore the Paradise of Phi Phi Islands By Alejandro Torres A...

    VIDEO | WOW – Tech giants harness nuclear energy to power AI | BBC News

    Technology firms are increasingly turning to nuclear sources of...

    UPDATE I – OPP Seeking Assistance in Theft of Retail Items from Midland Store

    Suspects Identified and Charged Through investigation and the assistance of...

    Georgian Bay News welcomes Dr. Bridget McMaster, ND

    “focus on yourself” Hi Georgian Bay News!  I am Dr. Bridget,...

    The Woman Who Helps NBA Stars To Sleep | Dr Cheri Mah

    Quicker decision making and faster reaction times, here's how...

    Youtuber Bank Won’t Let You Withdraw Money | Coffeezilla

    The no-lose "bank" turned out to be a lie....

    Industry hijacks global climate and biodiversity summits

    Under global consumer-capitalism, power and wealth are concentrated in...

    The Blue Mountains and Collingwood Kick Off Collaborative Multi-Use Recreation Feasibility Assessment

    Collingwood, ON  – The Town of The Blue Mountains and...

    OPP and CAFC Partner with Bulletin with More Information about Holiday Frauds

    (MIDLAND,ON)- Members of the Southern Georgian Bay Detachment of the Ontario Provincial Police (OPP)...

    In Conversation with David Frum: Will Chrystia Freeland’s resignation be Justin Trudeau’s undoing?

    Leading author, journalist and thinker David Frum and The...

    “Trump Is Going to Get a Lot of Wins:” Ian Bremmer Forecasts 2025 Geopolitics | Amanpour and Company

    From Russia's war in Ukraine to U.S. relations with...

    Local Live Lunch | Starring “The Browns Time Machine” and lunch by Black Bellows

    LOCAL LIVE LUNCH 10 Wednesdays! 10 Concerts! 10 Menus! JULY 10...

    Global: A Web of Surveillance

    Unravelling a murky network of spyware exports to Indonesia An...

    Guest Food on a Caribbean Super Yacht Charter

    Following on from my last video about how I...

    Polar Vortex Shifts, Unleashing Freezing Weather Across Canada | The Weather Network

    The Weather Network's Matt Hamel and meteorologist Laura Power...

    Plastic is polluting our brains and bodies!

    By David Suzuki Microplastics, soft plastics, burning plastics, plastics in...

    Navigating the Storm: Three Ways to Cope with Political Anxiety

    Navigating the Storm: Three Ways to Cope with Political...

    Calling All Young and Emerging Artists: Art Xpress is Back!

    Collingwood, ON – A must-see presentation - Art Xpress...

    How to Lie Your Way to $44 Billion | Saigon Commercial Bank Fraud

    What happens when one person owns a bank and...

    HURONIA WEST OPP INVESTIGATING A FATAL VEHICLE COLLISION INVOLVING A SNOWMOBILE

    (SPRINGWATER TOWNSHIP, ON) - The Huronia West Detachment of the...

    Fareed Zakaria on what Assad’s fall says about Russia

    CNN’s Fareed Zakaria explores what Syria’s stunning fall to...

    Industries in denial: From burning cigarettes to a burning planet

    By David Suzuki Not long ago, smoking was promoted as healthy —...

    Ally Vitally shares the “75 Scariest Attractions In The World!”

    Ever wondered what it feels like to confront your...

    Love Wins with the Collingwood Pride Festival 2024

    The Rainbow Club of South Georgian Bay (Rainbow Club) is...

    VIDEO | The $270 Billion Race to Replace the Panama Canal

    The Panama Canal, one of the greatest engineering marvels...

    Emperor penguin chicks jump off a 50-foot cliff in Antarctica NEVER-BEFORE-FILMED FOR TV

    Thanks for the share, Ron Misurka. National Geographic and BAFTA...

    The Next Computer? Your Glasses | Shahram Izadi | TED

    Picture this: you’re wearing a normal-looking pair of glasses,...

    Town of The Blue Mountains Statement on OPP Funding

    The Town of The Blue Mountains is welcoming the...

    Collingwood Pride Festival: Star-Studded Lineup and Exciting Events THIS July 12-13!

    Emma Nichol Photography Hello and Happy Friday from Pride Collingwood...

    GPT-5 Will Make GPT-4o Look Like a Toddler’s Toy!

    The potential of GPT-5, while speculative, promises to herald...