Saturday, October 4, 2025
More

    Top 6 This Week

    popular+

    Costly geoengineering schemes could stall real solutions

    Sharing is SO MUCH APPRECIATED!

    By David Suzuki

    Because the fossil fuel industry and its supporters have done everything they can to stall needed solutions to the climate crisis, some people say we must now engineer our way out of the mess we created. Many are promoting schemes that block sunlight from reaching Earth, reflect more of it back into space or absorb carbon from the atmosphere.

    Have we really reached that point? Would blocking sunlight by putting reflective particles such as toxic sulphur dioxide into the upper atmosphere cool the planet? Or spraying seawater into the lower atmosphere to increase reflective cloud cover? How about thickening ice with pumped seawater? Building massive machines to suck carbon from the air?

    What are the risks? What would be the unintended consequences?

    United Kingdom government office, the Advanced Research and Invention Agency, is spending £56.8 million (about C$106 million) to explore some of these “climate cooling approaches” or “climate interventions.”

    ARIA points out that “climate tipping points — abrupt changes in the Earth system that, if crossed, could have devastating and essentially irreversible consequences” are “distinctly possible over the next century.”

    It notes, however, that, “There is no substitute for decarbonisation, which is the only sustainable way to lower the chances of such tipping points and their effects from occurring.”

    Many scientists worry that these geoengineering plans are an expensive distraction from the need to cut emissions and that they could have severe unforeseen and undesirable environmental consequences.

    As the Guardian reports, the Arctic and Antarctic are heating much faster than the rest of the planet, which has focused attention on ways to cool the poles. Melting ice exposes more dark land and water, which absorb solar radiation rather than reflecting it. Proposals include increasing ice cover by pumping seawater onto it or scattering glass beads onto the ice to reflect more sunlight.

    New research published in Frontiers in Science suggests that methods being considered for polar regions are flawed and only treat the symptoms and not the causes of global heating.

    “These geoengineering proposals are unimaginably expensive and risky for fragile polar environments,” said University of Massachusetts Amherst professor Rob DeConto, one of 42 scientists behind the analysis. “They also detract attention from the root cause of the climate crisis — the unabated burning of fossil fuels, something we know how to begin addressing using established technologies.”

    The researchers conclude that money and effort would be put to better use in reducing the emissions that are the primary cause of global heating.

    “We’re hopeful that we can eliminate emissions by 2050,” University of Exeter professor Martin Siegert, who led the analysis, said. “Anything that drifts us away from doing that will make the world less safe and less habitable.”

    The Guardian reports that, in reviewing polar geoengineering schemes, researchers examined six criteria: “effectiveness, cost, scale and time issues, environment risks, governance challenges and the risk of raising false hopes.” The plans failed on all counts.

    The researchers point out that methods such as pumping seawater onto polar ice and scattering tiny glass beads onto the ice are, respectively, “technologically, logistically and financially unrealistic” and “could be toxic to wildlife.”

    Some are clearly designed to allow the destructive fossil fuel industry to keep operating. In Canada, the government has just announced plans for a costly “carbon capture, utilization and storage” project in the Alberta oilsands, hyping the plan as a way to “support a strong conventional energy sector while driving down emissions and emissions intensity.” But they just count production emissions, which are only a fraction of the deadly emissions from burning the fuels.

    Cost for renewable energy and storage have plummeted, making these technologies far more cost-effective than fossil fuels — and they’re more efficient.

    There’s no good reason to keep the polluting, climate-altering fossil fuel industry going, other than to put more money into the pockets of oligarchs and shareholders and give governments easy ways to make the economy appear healthy over the short term, while putting everyone’s health and survival at risk.

    We may well be at the point where we have to consider drastic measures to reduce greenhouse gases in the atmosphere, but it shouldn’t be at the expense of going all out on solutions that have already proven to be effective.

    David Suzuki is a scientist, broadcaster, author and co-founder of the David Suzuki Foundation. Written with David Suzuki Foundation Senior Writer and Editor Ian Hanington.

    Learn more at davidsuzuki.org.

    REFERENCES:

    United Kingdom government office:

    https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2025/may/07/real-world-geoengineering-experiments-revealed-by-uk-agency

    ARIA points out:

    https://www.aria.org.uk/opportunity-spaces/future-proofing-our-climate-and-weather/exploring-climate-cooling

    Geoengineering plans are an expensive distraction:

    https://davidsuzuki.org/story/the-promises-and-perils-of-geoengineering

    The Guardian reports:

    https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2025/sep/09/polar-geoengineering-branded-dangerous-and-unimaginably-expensive

    New research:

    https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/science/articles/10.3389/fsci.2025.1527393/full

    Martin Siegert, who led the analysis, said:

    Government has just announced plans:

    https://www.canada.ca/en/one-canadian-economy/news/2025/09/major-projects-office-of-canada-initial-projects-under-consideration.html

    More cost-effective than fossil fuels:

    https://www.irena.org/News/pressreleases/2025/Jul/91-Percent-of-New-Renewable-Projects-Now-Cheaper-Than-Fossil-Fuels-Alternatives

    Polluting, climate-altering fossil fuel industry:

    https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2025/sep/10/link-oil-giants-heatwaves-research-legal-liability

    Sharing is SO MUCH APPRECIATED!

    Leave a Reply

    This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

    Popular Articles

    GEORGIANBAYNEWS.COM

    Popular Articles

    Tariff delay a result of ‘depraved’ Trump tactics: Fmr. U.S. treasury secretary | Power & Politics

    Former U.S. treasury secretary Larry Summers says he doesn't think Canada has done anything significantly different to warrant a 30-day pause on U.S. President...

    Flags Flying at Half-Mast in Remembrance of Joan Gaudet

    The Town of The Blue Mountains will be flying the Town Hall flags at half-mast to mark the passing of community member Joan Gaudet....

    What’s behind the rising cost of your pet’s care? | Marketplace

    More than half of Canadians now have a pet in their home, and the cost of caring for those animals continues to climb. Marketplace...

    County launches 2025 Bursary Program to support local students and families

    Midhurst/April 15, 2025 – The County of Simcoe is committed to working with member municipalities to support the pursuit of higher education. Through the County’s...

    Ways to Honour National Day for Truth and Reconciliation

    Collingwood, ON - National Day for Truth and Reconciliation is observed on September 30, a day to reflect on the painful and lasting...

    YIKES!!! Why Trump Supporters Are Having MASSIVE Regrets in 2025!

    SCARED KETCHUP IS 90% to 100% FAN FUNDED... so if you're feelin' it... Paypal: https://paypal.me/scaredketchup?count...  / scaredketchup   https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kN1b7JFdOro SCARED KETCHUP IS 90% to 100% FAN FUNDED... so...

    A WHOLE NEW WORLD OF MUSIC IS COMING TO COLLINGWOOD!

      Hello Theatre Lovers! I am beyond thrilled to invite you to a truly magical event happening this May—an unforgettable evening that celebrates one of the most beloved...

    Celebrate May is Museum Month in Collingwood

    Explore the lasting popularity of Blue Mountain Pottery in a new temporary exhibit featured in our Community Collectors case. Collingwood, ON –  The Collingwood Museum is offering a...

    The Blue Mountains Public Library Announces 30th Anniversary Celebrations

    This release is being shared by the Town on behalf of The Blue Mountains Public Library The Blue Mountains Public Library (BMPL) is celebrating its...

    Collingwood welcomes Dr. Matthew Ladda to Town

    Collingwood, ON  – Collingwood now has a new family doctor, thanks to a new program that helps bring doctors to our town. Other towns...

    Love Wins with the Collingwood Pride Festival 2024

    The Rainbow Club of South Georgian Bay (Rainbow Club) is proud to officially announce the return of the Collingwood Pride Festival to Collingwood, Ontario. Collingwood Pride will be a festival and...

    The Unsettling Silence: Major Declines in Our Bee Populations and the Fragile Web of Life

    Bees, those tiny architects of nature, are facing a crisis of unprecedented scale. The gentle hum of a foraging bee, a seemingly ubiquitous sound of...

    FIREWORKS VIDEO | Happy Canada Day from Collingwood 2024

    We all enjoyed a spectacular fireworks display launched from Millennium Point on Canada Day! https://youtu.be/VaxupH_Us6o

    This is the Richest Old Money Family in Canada…Basically Own Canada.

    Forget the politicians you see on TV or the CEOs on magazine covers. The real, lasting power in Canada is often held by a...

    Pump Track Fundraiser Oct 5th | Old Village (Legion) Park

    The Event is open to bikes, scooters, skateboard and roller blades!2-3pm timed laps around the track see if you can beat your time! 3-4 open...

    What if the U.S. invaded Canada? | Front Burner

    U.S. President Donald Trump says he wants to make Canada the 51st state. What would that look like if it included not only tariffs...

    Mike Foley shares “School Violence is out of Control In Ontario Schools”.

    It‘s really important not to see this as bad kids or demonize kids. This is truly structural violence. This is institutional violence. This is...

    Frankie Malloy and Friends shares “Let’s Find EMBER and BRUTUS a Forever Family”.

    Happy Canada Day Pawsome furiends!  Share far and wide to find our furry friends a new home – Love, Frankie Malloy Meet Ember Ember is a 4 months old female Large Mixed Breed who weighs...

    States of Emergency ended in some municipalities across Simcoe County

    Service impacts and clean up continue during recovery phase Midhurst/April 11, 2025 – As of April 11, 2025, the County of Simcoe and several municipalities across...

    Pickleball Doubles Strategy Masterclass (pickleball tips to win at any level)

    Improve your Pickleball game with this Doubles Strategy Masterclass! Packed with top-notch pickleball tips and strategies, this guide is a must-watch for both beginners...

    #JESUS: Trump reverses course on relations with China as Elon Musk exerts influence

    CNN's Will Ripley reports on Chinese Vice President Han Zeng making the historic move to attend president-elect Donald Trump's second inauguration and how it...

    REGISTRATION OPENS T0NIGHT FOR 2025 OJHL COMBINE

    Eighth annual event designed to identify OJHL-quality players in Oakville April 22-25 January 22, 2025 - Mississauga, ON – The Ontario Junior Hockey League announced today that registration for...

    The Scoop Georgian Bay | OFFICIAL FIRST EPISODE!

    Hi all, I was on The Scoop Georgian Bay. Please enjoy our show! - Casey Thanks for your patience in the release of our...

    The Great History of Webers Burgers: An Ontario Institution on Highway 11

    From a humble roadside stand to a beloved landmark, explore the enduring legacy of Webers Burgers at 8825 Highway 11, Ontario. When radio traffic reporters...