Saturday, October 4, 2025
More

    Top 6 This Week

    popular+

    This Economic Story doesn’t End Well. Let’s Change it!

    Sharing is SO MUCH APPRECIATED!

    By David Suzuki

    The natural world is foundational to every aspect of our lives. We all need food, air and water. But nature is not our sole underpinning; stories are also foundational. Without them, we wouldn’t be able to make sense of the world or create meaning within it.

    Nature sustains human economies. More broadly speaking, economies are built on commonly held stories through which we agree on the means to exchange goods and services and ascribe value to products and labour. Economics is a societal story as are the narratives that propel it.

    These narratives can infuse us with longing, contentment or fear (among other emotions). The ones that capitalize on longing or fear are often spun by those with something to gain from their proliferation — those in power seeking to justify their actions, or people selling things.

    A successful narrative fuelling policy-making today is that environmental safeguards delay development and hinder extractive activities and are thus obstacles to “progress.”

    Examples abound. They include passage of British Columbia’s Bill 15, the Infrastructure Projects Act, under which ventures “in the provincial interest” (such as mines and fracked gas activities) can be fast-tracked. Similarly, Bill C5, the federal Building Canada Act, enables expediting infrastructure deemed to be in the “national interest.” The recently passed Bill 5, the Protect Ontario by Unleashing Our Economy Act, discards the Endangered Species Act while granting unfettered power to Ontario’s premier, cabinet and, by proxy, their “trusted proponents” to disregard environmental and other regulatory measures in yet-to-be-determined “special economic zones” — including the Ring of Fire, an area of mineral deposits in northern Ontario on First Nations’ traditional territories.

    These pieces of legislation imply that upholding Indigenous rights also impedes economic progress, as each was designed with the potential to bypass standard processes for consultation, and none embeds Canada’s international commitment to obtain free, prior and informed consent from Indigenous nations before approving development.

    Politicians advancing these acts have adorned them with imagery of Canadian prosperity, strength and sovereignty in the face of economic uncertainty unleashed by the U.S. administration.

    Economic instability provides fertile ground in which fear-based narratives can take hold. The floundering economy in Germany fomented Nazism, the story that subversives and radicals were responsible for the country’s economic problems fuelled the military junta in Argentina, and Trump came to power in the U.S. after spinning tales of rigged systems and immigrants stealing jobs.

    In Canada, the narrative that environmental protections should be ditched to fast-track resource extraction has been so successful that Ontario and Alberta’s premiers wrote to the prime minister demanding that, to “counter the impacts of the United States trade policy,” remaining federal environmental protection measures should be repealed — including the Impact Assessment Act, Clean Electricity Regulations, Greenhouse Gas Pollution Pricing Act and Species at Risk Act. They even had the gall to demand that the federal government “refrain from reintroducing” an act “respecting water, source water, drinking water, wastewater and related infrastructure on First Nation lands.”

    Indigenous land and rights defenders have been among the most vocal opponents of these deregulation initiatives. In Ontario, nine First Nations issued a legal challenge to strike down Ontario’s Bill 5 and the federal Bill C5, arguing that, “delay results from Crown choices and unwieldy bureaucracies, not from First Nations,” and asserting that, “Making changes now in some effort to ‘streamline’ (or ram through) projects, cannot be at the cost of First Nations, their rights, the Constitution and reconciliation.”

    We often buy into mainstream narratives without realizing it. Many people simply accept the story that regulations to protect the environment are an unnecessary hindrance, despite evidence that Canada’s existing safeguards have been insufficient to halt or reverse biodiversity loss.

    No one can force us to accept the stories spun by others. We are free to articulate stories of our own that counter those prioritizing short-term economic gains from resource extraction over long-term planning for a healthy future. Many of us share stories of Canada wherein Indigenous rights and responsibilities are upheld, and the knowledge that we can’t have healthy economies without healthy ecosystems to support them is recognized. These stories don’t merely reflect back a different reality; they help to shape a different future.

    David Suzuki is a scientist, broadcaster, author and co-founder of the David Suzuki Foundation. Written with David Suzuki Foundation Boreal Project Manager Rachel Plotkin.

    Learn more at davidsuzuki.org.

    REFERENCES:

    B.C.’s Bill 15:

    https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/bc-ndp-bill-15-1.7546636

    Fracked gas activities:

    https://davidsuzuki.org/story/fracked-lng-is-a-washed-out-bridge-to-nowhere

    Bill C5:

    https://davidsuzuki.org/expert-article/nation-building-isnt-just-about-speed-its-about-vision

    Bill 5:

    https://davidsuzuki.org/expert-article/indigenous-rights-arent-optional

    Ring of Fire:

    https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/toronto/ring-of-fire-special-economic-zone-ontario-1.7553352

    Ontario and Alberta’s premiers sent a letter to the prime minister:

    Nine First Nations issued a legal challenge:

    https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/toronto/first-nations-legal-challenge-against-ontario-bill-five-1.7585361

    Have been insufficient:

    https://www.facetsjournal.com/doi/10.1139/facets-2020-0075

    Sharing is SO MUCH APPRECIATED!

    Popular Articles

    GEORGIANBAYNEWS.COM

    Popular Articles

    Construction Notice – Thornbury West Reconstruction Phase 1B

    On behalf of the Town of The Blue Mountains, Tatham Engineering has completed preliminary design, detailed design and tendering for the Thornbury West Reconstruction -...

    SO MUCH FUN!!! Blue Mountain Retro Pond Skim | March 29, 2025

    Retro Pond Skim: A Splashy Send-Off to Ski Season As the snowy slopes of Blue Mountain Resort begin to soften under the late March sun,...

    The Gordie Howe International Bridge | The $6.4BN Bridge Between Canada & the US

    The busiest segment of the US-Canada border is set to open a brand new major crossing: The Gordie Howe International Bridge! Once completed, it...

    Youtuber Bank Won’t Let You Withdraw Money | Coffeezilla

    The no-lose "bank" turned out to be a lie. It’s now a casino you cant withdraw from. I’m making this video in the hopes...

    Why You Should Never Go Outside Without Sunscreen: Insights from Dermatologists

    When we think about health, a myriad of practices and precautions likely come to mind—eating well, exercising regularly, and getting enough sleep. However, one...

    The Amazing “Wee Willi Winkels” – Creator of the Snowboard | Blue Mountain Resort

    Wee Willi Winkels, a significant figure in the early development of snowboarding and skateboarding. Born in Germany in 1956 and immigrating to Canada as...

    OPP Conduct Two Impaired by Drug Investigations in One Day

    (MIDLAND, ON) - Officers of the Southern Georgian Bay Detachment of the Ontario Provincial Police (OPP) conducted two impaired driving investigations on May 7, 2025 on North Simcoe area patrolled roadways. The OPP...

    Join the Affordable Housing Task Force in celebrating YIMBY Week (Yes In My Back Yard) 

    Collingwood, ON - Neighbours say Yes In My Back Yard in support of affordable housing! Join Collingwood’s Affordable Housing Task Force in celebrating YIMBY...

    Emergency Preparedness Week in Simcoe County

    May 4 to 10, 2025 Midhurst/May 5, 2025 – The County of Simcoe is once again reminding residents about the importance of preparing themselves and their...

    IMPAIRED DRIVER ON CHRISTMAS EVE | Wasaga Beach

    (Wasaga Beach, ON) - Officers from the Huronia West OPP were able to respond promptly on Christmas Eve to reports of a black sedan driving...

    OPP Warn of Rising ‘Grandparent Scams’ During Fraud Prevention Month

    (COLLINGWOOD, ON) - The Ontario Provincial Police (OPP) Collingwood and The Blue Mountains Detachment is urging residents to remain vigilant following multiple reports of fraudulent...

    The Ultimate Road Trip: 18 Must Stops from Sault Ste. Marie to Thunder Bay

    Northern Ontario Road Trip from Sault Ste. Marie to Thunder Bay around Lake Superior is an absolute must-road trip! This scenic Lake Superior coastal...

    How Flying Cars Became a Billion-Dollar Bet | Bloomberg Primer

    The idea of flying cars has largely remained science fiction, until now. A new generation of electrified aircraft is attracting the attention of investors...

    2025 Grey County Road Projects in the Town of The Blue Mountains

    The Town of The Blue Mountains would like to advise the public of upcoming Grey County road projects happening within the Town of The...

    Calling All Emerging Performers – Busking Applications Now Open!

    Collingwood, ON - Street entertainment brings a special kind of energy to public spaces. The Town of Collingwood encourages responsible busking to enliven...

    OPP LAYS CHARGES IN DRIVEWAY PAVING FRAUD

    The Ontario Provincial Police (OPP) Anti-Rackets Branch (ARB) has laid criminal charges against two individuals following an investigation into driveway paving fraud spanning several regions...

    Wasaga Beach Hootenanny | October 12th, 2024

    By October, summer may be done, but the party isn’t over in Wasaga Beach—it’s Hootenanny season! In celebration of fall, we bring out the...

    County further expands open data portal with insights into the early learning and child care system across the region

    Midhurst/December 11, 2024 – The County of Simcoe has once again expanded its open data portal, easily accessed at open.simcoe.ca, now delivering insights into the region’s...

    The Ambassador: Canada and Ontario’s Strategic Framework for Navigating U.S. Tariff Volatility

    Canada’s Strategies for Thriving Amid Trump’s Unpredictable Trade Policies Canada faces significant challenges in managing its trade relationship with the United States under President Donald...

    OPP PARTNERS ON “RESCU” INITIATIVE TO LOCATE MISSING CHILDREN

    Public Encouraged to Register for Child Search Alerts (ORILLIA, ON) - The Ontario Provincial Police (OPP) is proud to announce today, in recognition of Missing Children's...

    Why some workers won’t have time to adapt to AI | DW News

    AI will replace millions of jobs, with the biggest risk posed to clerical jobs, which will primarily affect women, says Gilbert Houngbo, Director-General of...

    Resignation of Chief Administrative Officer Shawn Everitt

    The Town of The Blue Mountains would like to notify the public that Chief Administrative Officer (CAO) Shawn Everitt has resigned from his position,...

    Holey Moley shares: Cabbage with eggs tastes better than meat recipe! Easy, quick and very delicious!

    Cabbage with eggs tastes better than meat! Easy, quick and very delicious dinner recipe. Delicious and quick recipe for cabbage with onions! You won't...

    Marc Suood shares “A Good Reset to Up You’re Pickleball Game”

    Every Saturday, Marc Suood shares a pickleball video or two, with us. Never Stop Learning! Hope the great play of these athletes will inspire you!...