Saturday, October 25, 2025
More

    Top 6 This Week

    popular+

    This Economic Story doesn’t End Well. Let’s Change it!

    Sharing is SO MUCH APPRECIATED!

    By David Suzuki

    The natural world is foundational to every aspect of our lives. We all need food, air and water. But nature is not our sole underpinning; stories are also foundational. Without them, we wouldn’t be able to make sense of the world or create meaning within it.

    Nature sustains human economies. More broadly speaking, economies are built on commonly held stories through which we agree on the means to exchange goods and services and ascribe value to products and labour. Economics is a societal story as are the narratives that propel it.

    These narratives can infuse us with longing, contentment or fear (among other emotions). The ones that capitalize on longing or fear are often spun by those with something to gain from their proliferation — those in power seeking to justify their actions, or people selling things.

    A successful narrative fuelling policy-making today is that environmental safeguards delay development and hinder extractive activities and are thus obstacles to “progress.”

    Examples abound. They include passage of British Columbia’s Bill 15, the Infrastructure Projects Act, under which ventures “in the provincial interest” (such as mines and fracked gas activities) can be fast-tracked. Similarly, Bill C5, the federal Building Canada Act, enables expediting infrastructure deemed to be in the “national interest.” The recently passed Bill 5, the Protect Ontario by Unleashing Our Economy Act, discards the Endangered Species Act while granting unfettered power to Ontario’s premier, cabinet and, by proxy, their “trusted proponents” to disregard environmental and other regulatory measures in yet-to-be-determined “special economic zones” — including the Ring of Fire, an area of mineral deposits in northern Ontario on First Nations’ traditional territories.

    These pieces of legislation imply that upholding Indigenous rights also impedes economic progress, as each was designed with the potential to bypass standard processes for consultation, and none embeds Canada’s international commitment to obtain free, prior and informed consent from Indigenous nations before approving development.

    Politicians advancing these acts have adorned them with imagery of Canadian prosperity, strength and sovereignty in the face of economic uncertainty unleashed by the U.S. administration.

    Economic instability provides fertile ground in which fear-based narratives can take hold. The floundering economy in Germany fomented Nazism, the story that subversives and radicals were responsible for the country’s economic problems fuelled the military junta in Argentina, and Trump came to power in the U.S. after spinning tales of rigged systems and immigrants stealing jobs.

    In Canada, the narrative that environmental protections should be ditched to fast-track resource extraction has been so successful that Ontario and Alberta’s premiers wrote to the prime minister demanding that, to “counter the impacts of the United States trade policy,” remaining federal environmental protection measures should be repealed — including the Impact Assessment Act, Clean Electricity Regulations, Greenhouse Gas Pollution Pricing Act and Species at Risk Act. They even had the gall to demand that the federal government “refrain from reintroducing” an act “respecting water, source water, drinking water, wastewater and related infrastructure on First Nation lands.”

    Indigenous land and rights defenders have been among the most vocal opponents of these deregulation initiatives. In Ontario, nine First Nations issued a legal challenge to strike down Ontario’s Bill 5 and the federal Bill C5, arguing that, “delay results from Crown choices and unwieldy bureaucracies, not from First Nations,” and asserting that, “Making changes now in some effort to ‘streamline’ (or ram through) projects, cannot be at the cost of First Nations, their rights, the Constitution and reconciliation.”

    We often buy into mainstream narratives without realizing it. Many people simply accept the story that regulations to protect the environment are an unnecessary hindrance, despite evidence that Canada’s existing safeguards have been insufficient to halt or reverse biodiversity loss.

    No one can force us to accept the stories spun by others. We are free to articulate stories of our own that counter those prioritizing short-term economic gains from resource extraction over long-term planning for a healthy future. Many of us share stories of Canada wherein Indigenous rights and responsibilities are upheld, and the knowledge that we can’t have healthy economies without healthy ecosystems to support them is recognized. These stories don’t merely reflect back a different reality; they help to shape a different future.

    David Suzuki is a scientist, broadcaster, author and co-founder of the David Suzuki Foundation. Written with David Suzuki Foundation Boreal Project Manager Rachel Plotkin.

    Learn more at davidsuzuki.org.

    REFERENCES:

    B.C.’s Bill 15:

    https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/bc-ndp-bill-15-1.7546636

    Fracked gas activities:

    https://davidsuzuki.org/story/fracked-lng-is-a-washed-out-bridge-to-nowhere

    Bill C5:

    https://davidsuzuki.org/expert-article/nation-building-isnt-just-about-speed-its-about-vision

    Bill 5:

    https://davidsuzuki.org/expert-article/indigenous-rights-arent-optional

    Ring of Fire:

    https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/toronto/ring-of-fire-special-economic-zone-ontario-1.7553352

    Ontario and Alberta’s premiers sent a letter to the prime minister:

    Nine First Nations issued a legal challenge:

    https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/toronto/first-nations-legal-challenge-against-ontario-bill-five-1.7585361

    Have been insufficient:

    https://www.facetsjournal.com/doi/10.1139/facets-2020-0075

    Sharing is SO MUCH APPRECIATED!

    Popular Articles

    GEORGIANBAYNEWS.COM

    Popular Articles

    The Blue Mountains Public Library Announces 30th Anniversary Celebrations

    This release is being shared by the Town on behalf of The Blue Mountains Public Library The Blue Mountains Public Library (BMPL) is celebrating its...

    Why China and the US are so obsessed with Taiwan | Mapped Out

    The US-China superpower rivalry is on full display in Taiwan. Beijing wants control of the island and is willing to use force to get...

    Rise of the assholes: why do we keep rewarding bad behaviour?

    Ever get the impression that assholes are taking over? Assholes: A Theory, a timely new doc from John Walker, investigates the breeding grounds of...

    Thriving in Simplicity: The Tiny House Community Advantage

    Affordable Living, Sustainable Choices, and Stronger Bonds Living in a tiny house community offers a unique blend of simplicity, sustainability, and social connection that appeals...

    Special Meeting of Council – January 10, 2025

    The January 10, 2025 Special Council Meeting Agenda Package is now available for review. The meeting will begin at 9:30 a.m. Members of the...

    Alberta energy sector concerned about new U.S. tariffs

    Alberta's energy producers are concerned about 10 per cent U.S. tariff and Canada's retaliatory response. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qfPyexmldSc »»» Subscribe to CBC News to watch more videos:...

    Ally Vitally: Julian Assange’s Plea Deal

    The WikiLeaks founder has been held in a British prison for the last five years and fought extradition to the U.S. He is expected...

    The Wild West of Condo Politics | The Agenda

    In Ontario there is, sort of, another level of government for 1.3 million people that is not federal, provincial or municipal. But for those...

    Global Crossroads: Politics and Technology Shape Our Future

    Yesterday's Pivotal Moments in World Affairs and Innovation In a rapidly evolving global landscape, yesterday marked significant developments across both political and technological spheres. From...

    By train to Hudson Bay | DW Documentary

    Anyone who wants to travel overland from Winnipeg to Churchill has to take the train. Only one track leads through Canada's tundra to Hudson...

    HURONIA WEST OPP LOOKING FOR THE PUBLICS ASSISTANCE REGARDING AN ARMED ROBBERY

    (WASAGA BEACH, ON) - Members of the Huronia West Detachment of the Ontario Provincial Police (OPP) are requesting the public's assistance regarding an armed robbery that...

    VIDEO: America’s Lonely Future: David Frum on Trump’s “Predatory” Foreign Policy

    With Trump's inauguration on the horizon, conversations continue about the impact of the President-elect's policies both at home and abroad. David Frum is a...

    CENTENNIAL CUP WIN EXTRA SPECIAL FOR COLLINGWOOD KIDS ON COLLINGWOOD BLUES’ ROSTER

    OJHL reporter Ron Valentine with Collingwood Blues Marcus Lougheed (right) and Dame Boose at the Centennial Cup postgame celebration in Oakville Sunday. (Photo by...

    County of Simcoe Long-Term Care homes host Bring a Friend to Volunteer Days

    Midhurst/February 5, 2025 – This February and March, the County invites those interested in making a difference in the lives of older adults to check...

    Not So Pro Volleyball Tournament 2025 | Wasaga Beach

    This is our 27th year in Wasaga and the Beach Volleyball games and the social are incredible! Last year we had 100 teams and 750...

    Erin McCallum & Teddy Leonard: Alone Together | John Saunders Centre

    Back, by popular request, the 3rd “Alone Together” show will take place at the intimate Bluesee’s Lounge - an intimate space at the John...

    Praise Fest | FREE fun family Sunday in the Park

    Praise Fest - September 10, 2023 - 12:00 pm to 4:00 pm Bring a lawn chair and enjoy a FREE fun family Sunday in the park, at the...

    OPP ANNOUNCES THE SEIZURE OF 435,000 POTENTIALLY LETHAL DOSES OF FENTANYL FROM TWO SEPARATE INVESTIGATIONS

    Historic Investigation Results (ORILLIA, ON) -Today, the Ontario Provincial Police (OPP) has announced the results of two major investigations that resulted in a historic seizure of...

    Collingwood OPP Investigate Parked Vehicle, Driver Charged with Impaired Operation

    (COLLINGWOOD, ON) - On the afternoon of December 12, 2024, members of the Ontario Provincial Police responded to a call for service about a male...

    Meaford Haunted Harbour | Premiere Scary Event

    Grab your big kid pants and head on down to the water where we are finally putting on a haunted house at the Meaford...

    YMCA – Move to Give Officially Kicks Off!

    Move to Give officially kicked off this week with some exciting events - the Y Ride in Collingwood, Rubber Duck Race in Midland, and Cycle-a-Thon...

    The Daniel Lanois Trio | August 7-8 | Meaford Hall

    Thursday, August 7 and Friday, August 8 7:30pm | $99.50VIDEO: Daniel Lanois & Heavy Sun That’s The Way It Is Daniel Lanois is a name that...

    Mike Malloy shares “Elon Musk Is Taking Over”.

    Elon Musk is rapidly consolidating control over large swaths of the federal government with President Donald Trump ’s blessing, sidelining career officials, gaining access...

    🎥 Top 10 Selkirk Pickleball Plays of 2024 🏓 ✨

    Get ready for the ultimate highlight reel! 🎥 🏓 We’re counting down the Top 10 PPA Pickleball Plays from 2024, showcasing the most jaw-dropping...